I can't offer a comparison between these two windshileds but I have the CeeGlide windshield. I have ridden behind it for 60,000 miles now and love it! I have the 13" dark smoke, but as said in a previous post, it doesn't offer a passenger great protection. My wife rides her own so I haven't had to worry about a passenger. I guess if I had to start carrying a passenger I would have to get to a light smoke and get a taller windshield to accomodate the passenger. The Madstad must be a great product as most everyone who trys them likes them, but I just can't get past the looks. I don't need no air, just no buffeting and the Ceeglide does this for me.