Freedom vote here
I'm 5'7 and had a 12 inch Freedom on my '17, and now my '18. The obvious advantage with Freedom is you can try it and if you want to go higher or lower, you can (I started with a 10, tried an 11, ended with a 12).. The quality is excellent
2018 Road Glide Special. 12 inch 'Freedom' shield, Mustang seat, Harley tour pak, Advanblack lowers, Motolights, rear crash bars, Headset plug-in, Ciro footpegs, Black headlamp trim, mesh grill covers, Flash2open garage transmitter, buncha other stuff!!