Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Laurel, Maryland
Believe it or not.
I had always hear they were THE most expensive insurance carriers around but they done me right.
I had been paying $650.00/yr for liability only with Allstate on my 11yr old Kaw but now I pay $500/yr for full coverage on my 2011, HD, Road Glide.
My coverage sounds about the same as what you're getting.
I would get a quote from Progressive online and take that to Geico.
I make no promises, your experience may vary.
Maybe not though.