I have an independent agent as well and ran DairyLand for several years because I needed a SR22 for letting the insurance lapse while I had one of the MC in storage. (Really stupid AZ law). Then I did the 2003 Heritage Softail Trike conversion, the accessory add with DairyLand was extreme. Now I have Progressive but even that is extreme to fully insure that Trike and my declared value on the 1983 FXDG, 80th Anniversary Edition. I will be shopping again probably without my independent agent as that was the best she could do for me.
I tried haggerty but they would not insure the trike at all.
State Farm is blitzing the air waves here claiming much reduced rates, might be a good first shot.
I have the cars with Travellers, and those rates are very good, but no MC coverage offered.
1982 FLT Virgin unmolested barn find.
1983 FXDG 80th Anniversary AKA Willie G Disc Glide, 10.5 to 1, Andrews B grind, 2002 Fat boy carb, Barnett Clutch, drag pipes.
2003 FLTSCI Black and Silver converted with Motor Trike Kit plus HD tour pak, 88 inch, HD 204 Cam, Vance & Hines mid shots.