I will give my newly installed kw 14 sport flare a 10 for appearance---however im only going to rate it a 6 for performance due to the distortion in the curves and the vibration of shield..wind deflection is alot better that stock but could be a little better . Im considering a freedom shield and would like some feedback from anyone who has tried one. I like that the freedom is about a 16'th of an inch thicker in material but im only going by website. Also seems to look good, not as good as kw but will give that aspect a little slack if it performs better. Any input would be appreciated ( i know, i know, i know----madstad right ? Not gonna happen til i see one in person and decide if i can get past the look......lol