Road Glide banner

1 - 20 of 185 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,202 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
After opening up the primary for an oil leak I noticed, like others recently that the SE comp I installed a few years ago to replace my stock comp needs replacing again. There's been talk about the Vulcanworks solid sprocket being the last one anyone needs to buy and those who are using it seem to like. I personally don't think that's the one for me because my motor is a stock 96" with 35k miles on it. There's also been talk about the BDL compensator. The BDL has my interest because it seems that it puts itself somewhere between the Vulcan and the updated SE comp from the MoCo sorta speak. Does anyone here use the BDL and have some good milage in it to give a decent review of it? I email their tech dept to get info. Here's what they replied in case anyone maybe wondering the same as I am. --------"Hey Rob, Our CS-34A is a steel compensator that has (2) Nylatron washers, There is (1) larger washer that is recessed into the sprocket face on the inner side, and a smaller washer recessed into the outer face of the sprocket, the sprocket and sprocket carrier body are both threaded, the sprocket can rotate either clockwise or counter clockwise 1-2 teeth, this absorbs the shock of the hard downshifting and starting kickbacks, the sprocket will stay up against the stator rotor until it needs to counter rotate to absorb any shock. The CS-34A consists of (1) sprocket, (1) sprocket carrier body, (1) outer flange, (1) large Nylatron washer and (1) small Nylatron washer. Thank You for your interest, Scott"------- if anyone has first hand experience with the BDL compensator please shed some light for us. Thanks
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,042 Posts
There's also one supposedly coming from DarkHorse crank works that works much like the cush-drive in our rear pulleys, but it's been long delayed in arrival.
It's such a seemingly simply application and concept, I really don't know why the MoCo can't come up with a better solution??
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,202 Posts
Discussion Starter #3
There's also one supposedly coming from DarkHorse crank works that works much like the cush-drive in our rear pulleys, but it's been long delayed in arrival.
It's such a seemingly simply application and concept, I really don't know why the MoCo can't come up with a better solution??
The cush drive thing may be something of interest. Is there any info on that or maybe a link possibly?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,687 Posts
I am running the vulcanworks and so are a few of my friends that ride 40+k per year. I don't see a downfall, if you are not downshifting hard and not constantly lugging or doing rabbit starts (preload in fun mode) the crank should be fine. I think the BDL is a great product but cannot attest to the durability since I have not run one. I would agree that the BDL would be a better option than the HD Comp. Good Luck
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
671 Posts
I'm running the BDL in my 113". So far, so good.. I've only been able to put about 2k miles on it this summer due to some health problems.. But I like the design and it seems to function properly. The installation instructions call for White Assembly Lube.. I couldn't find any locally and gave BDL a call.. Very good customer service and helpful over the phone.. They have changed there stance on the Assembly lube and recommended... Anti-Siege Lube.. (like you put on head bolts and muffler bolts.) The silver stuff that gets all over everything.. Coat it good,,, that stuff stays put..
All in all.. I'm happy so far.. We'll see how it hold up over the long haul. The way I look at it.. the worst case is that it freezes up.. Then it will be like running a solid sprocket.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
108 Posts
I'm running the BDL in my 113". So far, so good.. I've only been able to put about 2k miles on it this summer due to some health problems.. But I like the design and it seems to function properly. The installation instructions call for White Assembly Lube.. I couldn't find any locally and gave BDL a call.. Very good customer service and helpful over the phone.. They have changed there stance on the Assembly lube and recommended... Anti-Siege Lube.. (like you put on head bolts and muffler bolts.) The silver stuff that gets all over everything.. Coat it good,,, that stuff stays put..
All in all.. I'm happy so far.. We'll see how it hold up over the long haul. The way I look at it.. the worst case is that it freezes up.. Then it will be like running a solid sprocket.
What about noise did it quiet the primary clickyness?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,202 Posts
Discussion Starter #7
Heres another email i got from BDL regarding their compensator. Still trying to research alternative compensators other than HD equipment. Hopefull this will help others
" Rob, The CS-34A Compensator has been out since 2009, The only issues that I know about have been in the installation, There are (2) Nylatron washers that must be seated into their recess pockets, This is a very simple task. We have received less than 1% back* and from our inspection of these parts it has been limited to the Nylatron washers being pinched during installation and no application of proper Loctite applied to the mounting bolt. We do make running changes over time to adapt to different stator rotors as H-D makes their changes. I do recommend that if you decide to go with our CS-34A that you also change the H-D auto primary chain tensioner. I just do not like the way that it works with any compensator. I hope this helps you out. Thank You, Scott"
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,435 Posts
Heres another email i got from BDL regarding their compensator. Still trying to research alternative compensators other than HD equipment. Hopefull this will help others
" Rob, The CS-34A Compensator has been out since 2009, The only issues that I know about have been in the installation, There are (2) Nylatron washers that must be seated into their recess pockets, This is a very simple task. We have received less than 1% back* and from our inspection of these parts it has been limited to the Nylatron washers being pinched during installation and no application of proper Loctite applied to the mounting bolt. We do make running changes over time to adapt to different stator rotors as H-D makes their changes. I do recommend that if you decide to go with our CS-34A that you also change the H-D auto primary chain tensioner. I just do not like the way that it works with any compensator. I hope this helps you out. Thank You, Scott"
Hayden Tensioner?

They should send one to Tracy for the Shark Week IV Raffle. Might get a lot of tickets for that one. Can you send your contacts info to Tracy?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,202 Posts
Discussion Starter #9 (Edited)
Hayden Tensioner?

They should send one to Tracy for the Shark Week IV Raffle. Might get a lot of tickets for that one. Can you send your contacts info to Tracy?
The guys name is Scott who I've been talking to. I'm simply emailing BDL's tech support with my questions
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,042 Posts
Hayden Tensioner?

They should send one to Tracy for the Shark Week IV Raffle. Might get a lot of tickets for that one. Can you send your contacts info to Tracy?

Pretty sure Hayden has already sent Tracy a tensioner for the auction, unless she already culled out the parts she's keeping??
I won't be putting any tickets in, cuz I've already got one. Been using them for my last 3 bikes and have installed a couple in friends bikes.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,595 Posts
Based on all that I've read, I ordered The CS-34A Compensator from BDL on line last night.
I'm hoping that it works as described.
I already have the Hayden Tensioner in so I'm hoping the BDL quiets down my Primary noises which I believe are coming from the Useless Harley Compensator.
I'll keep you all posted.
Mike U.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,202 Posts
Discussion Starter #12
Based on all that I've read, I ordered The CS-34A Compensator from BDL on line last night.
I'm hoping that it works as described.
I already have the Hayden Tensioner in so I'm hoping the BDL quiets down my Primary noises which I believe are coming from the Useless Harley Compensator.
I'll keep you all posted.
Mike U.
Please keep us posted on your thoughts when you open the box to check it out for the first time too. From the emails I've been getting from them i would say it sounds good
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
12,310 Posts
I've been looking at the Vulcan works and Waiting for BDL, after reading about the BDL, when I do change again I think I'm going BDL.

Sent from Motorcycle.com Free App
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,202 Posts
Discussion Starter #14
Ive been asking them several questions about these comps because honestly I'm getting tired of hearing about the poor quality of the HD designs. BDL tech support has been great in actually responding to my emails. I know a lot of us are having compensator issues and I'm posting their replies to maybe help us all out. Here's another email i just received from them.

"Yes you will be able to use the stock stator rotor, We have adapted the CS-34A to accommodate either stator rotor 07-11 and 11-up, Hayden is a good choice, Thank You, Scott"
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,595 Posts
I was seriously thinking of going with the Vulcan Works Solid Sprocket until I read all I did about the BDL Compensator.
I'm waiting to here back from BDL as when they will be shipping me the CS-34A Compensator.
Mike U.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,202 Posts
Discussion Starter #16
I was seriously thinking of going with the Vulcan Works Solid Sprocket until I read all I did about the BDL Compensator.
Mike U.
Yeah me too but my concern is with my stock motor. I think some kind of dampening system is better than none. People that use the vulcanworks sprocket like it but I'm just nervous about it not having any kind of buffer
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,202 Posts
Discussion Starter #17
Having looked around a bit for the BDL compensator, I've been seeing that they maybe alil hard to come by. I did however order one from Phat Performance Parts. Their website said they had them in stock for $178. with free shipping. I guess I'll have to wait to see if it holds true
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,202 Posts
Discussion Starter #18
The BDL compensator got delivered yesterday. It's definitely a different design but looks like installation will be straight forward. I was going to wait a while to swap it out because I already had the primary apart twice in the past month to change a couple seals but I nay have time to get it done thus weekend. Fingers crossed
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,435 Posts
The BDL compensator got delivered yesterday. It's definitely a different design but looks like installation will be straight forward. I was going to wait a while to swap it out because I already had the primary apart twice in the past month to change a couple seals but I nay have time to get it done thus weekend. Fingers crossed
Need pictures :D
 
1 - 20 of 185 Posts
Top